Earthly Pet Pill Buddy Naturals Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Treats, 30-count (Size: 30-count)

Soft & Chewy Treats

$12.99

N-Bone Puppy Teething Rings Peanut Butter Flavor Dog Treats

Dental & Hard Chews

$16.99

Woof Calming Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats, X-Large

Treats

$23.99

Etta Says! Bakery-Fresh Cookie Crunchers Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$1.59

Super Snouts Hemp+JOINT BS Peanut Butter C B D for Dogs, 240mg

Vitamins & Supplements

$36.99

Super Snouts CHILL+OUT BS Peanut Butter C B D for Dogs, 240mg

Vitamins & Supplements

$36.99

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Sandwich Cookie Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$8.99

Woof Dog Allergy Support Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats Large

Treats

$20.99

Woof Dog Joint Health Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats, Large

Treats

$20.99

Woof Dog Allergy Support Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats Small

Treats

$20.99

Woof Dog Allergy Support Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats X-Large

Treats

$23.99

Woof Dog Joint Health Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats, X-Large

Treats

$23.99

Woof Dog Joint Health Wellness Pops Peanut Butter & Beef Dog Treats, Small

Treats

$20.99

HuggleHounds Jingle all the Way Rudy Knottie Dog Toy

Christmas, Plush Toys

Starting at $17.99

Rudy Reindeer Knottie® Durable Plush Dog Toy - Large

Dog, Toys

$22.99

Tropiclean Enticers Peanut Butter & Honey Teeth Cleaning Gel for Dogs

Toothpastes & Gels

$10.99

Rudy Reindeer Knottie® Durable Plush Dog Toy - Super Size

Dog, Toys

$37.99

Bocce's Bakery Bark Hearts Peanut Butter & Bacon Training Bites Dog Treats

Valentines Day, Training Treats

$6.99

The Honest Kitchen Goat's Milk N' Cookies Peanut Butter & Honey Dog Treats

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$12.99

Fromm Four-Star Nutritionals Pork & Peas Dry Dog Food

Dry Food

Starting at $17.99

ProDen PlaqueOff System Mini Dental Care Bones Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Treats

Dental & Hard Chews

$27.99

BIXBI Pocket Trainers Peanut Butter Flavor Grain-Free Dog Treats, 6-oz (Size: 6-oz)

Training Treats, Soft & Chewy Treats

$9.99

Bocce's Bakery Better Basics Peanut Butter and Banana Dog Biscuits, 14-oz (Size: 14-oz)

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$9.99

fabdog Fluffy Monster Dog Toy, Purple

Stuffed Toys

$19.99

fabdog Fluffy Monster Dog Toy, Pink

Stuffed Toys

$23.99

fabdog Fluffy Monster Dog Toy, Blue

Stuffed Toys

$15.99

Darford Mega Bacon Flavor Junior Bone Dog Treat, 3.5-oz (Size: 3.5-oz)

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$3.99

Adored Beast Apothecary Jump for JOYnts Regular Strength 4-Way Mobility Support Homeopathy for Dogs & Cats

Vitamins & Supplements

$30.99

Bocce's Bakery Moooo Moooo Cat Treats

Soft & Chewy Treats

$4.99

Fluff & Tuff Morley Mallard Dog Toy, Small (Size: Small)

Stuffed Toys

$14.99

ADV MILLY MONKEY LEATHER & ROPE

$7.99

Classic Collection HuggleFlatties™, 3-pack Assorted (St. Nick, Rudy and Snowman)

Dog, Toys

$11.99

NutriSource Chicken & Peas Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

Dry Food

$69.99

Open Farm Surf & Turf Morsels Raw Recipe Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Freeze-Dried Food

Starting at $10.99

Cloud Star Wag More Dental Biscuits

Biscuits & Crunchy Treats

$6.99

Open Farm Chicken & Salmon Morsels Raw Recipe Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Freeze-Dried Food

Starting at $10.99

Open Farm Harvest Chicken Morsels Raw Recipe Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Freeze-Dried Food

Starting at $10.99

Snugarooz Baby Momma Llama Dog Toy, 6-in

Toys

$6.99

Super Snouts Chews Daily Mobility 30ct

Dog, Vitamins & Supplements, Hip & Joint Care

$47.99

Huggle Hounds Holiday Mouse Knottie Dog Toy

Christmas, Toys

$26.99

Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon & Cod Morsels Raw Recipe Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Freeze-Dried Food

Starting at $10.99

ThoozyPet Tuff & Cuddly Monkey Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$15.99

HuggleHounds Cozy Cottagelong And Lovely Moose

Christmas, Toys

$16.99

NuloFreeStyle Cat Silky Mousse, Chicken & Duck

Wet Food

$1.69

Nulo FreeStyle Cat Silky Mousse, Beef & Sardine

Wet Food

$1.69